1 - 20 of 22 Works in Sam Winchester is Bad at Feelings

Pages Navigation

Listing Works

  1. Tags
    Summary

    His eyes are really blue. Like, vividly blue. How has he not noticed them before?

    Based on the tumblr prompt: “Sorry, I couldn’t help but notice that you don’t have an umbrella. We can share mine if you’d like.” + sastiel?

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    884
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    2
    Kudos:
    28
    Bookmarks:
    2
    Hits:
    162
  2. Tags
    Summary

    “Look! Sam, Dean, a play!”

    And damn it all if Dean doesn’t almost swerve off the road and crash as he takes in the sign.

    ‘Supernatural: The Musical. And of course, Marie’s face is plastered on the side. Don’t kids ever learn anything?

    “Dean hates that play.” Sam provides, as Dean continues to sulk in silence.

    He hates people knowing about his life. About things that he hadn’t even told his brother… things that he didn’t want to acknowledge as real.

    Cass frowns. “From what I can see it seems like it’s a fairly accurate portrayal of your lives.

    “Yeah, but it’s our lives Cass. It talks about all our rough patches and fights and every bad thing that ever happened. Why would we watch it?”

    “Because I want to see it. I’ve never seen a musical before.”

    “Yea, well, you can barely call this a musical.” He mutters, turning on his indicator anyway.

    ...

    Team Free Will 2.0 watch the supernatural play... only some things in the second act have changed.

    When Dean finds out Castiel thinks they could be a good couple how will he cope?

    Will he push him away?

    Or will unforeseen circumstances force them to face the music?

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    6,237
    Chapters:
    5/?
    Comments:
    18
    Kudos:
    104
    Bookmarks:
    12
    Hits:
    1352
  3. Tags
    Summary

    Sam deals with the aftermath of coming face-to-face with the demon that killed his mother and failing to take it out.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    640
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Kudos:
    4
    Bookmarks:
    1
    Hits:
    34
  4. Tags
    Summary

    “The way I feel about Dean cannot be expressed by the human tongue.” Cass says into the air as Sam is loading supplies into the Impala.

    He stops dead in his tracks and glances over to Cass who maintains the eye contact.

    “I wasn’t going to mention it.” he says with utter sincerity.

    Sam want to strange him. How many hints can someone drop? And how oblivious do you have to be to have missed every single one of them?

    “Can you go and not mention it to Dean?” he asks,

    “Why would I do that?” he asks incredulously. “Then I would be mentioning it to Dean.”

    “Then why do you keep ‘not mentioning these’ things to me?”

    Cass cocks his head. “I don’t know.” He says. “I just… you’re just there Sam. Don’t turn this onto me! I wasn’t even going to mention it.”

    Sam sighs as Cass marches out of the room, almost barrelling into Dean.

    “What’s up with him?” Dean asks, walking in and offering him a piece of bacon.

    He holds up a hand and waves the bacon away. “He just came to ‘not mention’ something.”

    Dean blinks at him in confusion.

    “What I’m saying Dean,” He says carefully. “is that you just need to let him down gently.”

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    1,000
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    10
    Kudos:
    179
    Bookmarks:
    10
    Hits:
    1588
  5. Tags
    Summary

    You've finally worked up the nerve to ask Sam out, but Sam thinks you're more into Dean than him.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    806
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Kudos:
    45
    Hits:
    527
  6. Tags
    Summary

    Castiel and Sam work on some fractures in their relationship. A gentle attempt at sensory play goes awry, leaving them scrambling to ratchet things back up to normal. Part of the 2020 Supernatural Kink Bingo.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    2,405
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    7
    Kudos:
    25
    Bookmarks:
    6
    Hits:
    287
  7. Tags
    Summary

    It’s strange how five little words can change your life forever.

    “I’m in love with Dean.”

    The words aren’t even directed at anyone… rather just said vaguely into the air.

    ...

    Big romantic gestures had never been his thing. But he knows, as much as Dean hates to admit it… he loves chick-flicks. He wants someone who will be over the top just because they love him. Maybe that’s why Sam hadn’t just told Cass to abandon the whole idea.

    Cass and Dean are already sitting in the kitchen when he wakes up and Dean is half surprised that Dean hasn’t already started bar hopping for women. When he whispers his concerns to Cass, the angel just whispers back: “I asked him to stay.”

    Sam is still standing there awestruck when Dean’s teeth make a loud clank.

    “Cass, did you forget a cinnamon stick or something in here.”

    Sam glances across at Cass who nervously leans against the table, analysing Dean’s every move. He assumes Cass is waiting till Dean is done with the pie to talk to him about his feelings.

    “Cass what the hell is this?” Dean’s voice is a combination of breathy, hopeful and terrified.

    Sam whips his gaze around to find Dean holding a silver ring coated in half-chewed pie.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    1,097
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    15
    Kudos:
    99
    Bookmarks:
    13
    Hits:
    1172
  8. Tags
    Summary

    “You’re a real Cass-anova, aren’t you?” He hears Dean mumble, but his mind sounds far away. “Man, your penmanship is crappy. You got a pen?” Dean asks.

    “A-at the bunker.”

    Sam is straining to see what’s written on the paper but it’s too crumpled and too far away. He knew he should have brought along his binoculars.

    “We have to leave then.” Dean says gruffly

    ...

    When Sam enters the bunker he’s drenched in complete silence. He had expected to walk in in the middle of their blow out.

    But silence.

    Sam’s eyes dart around looking for anything out of place. It takes him a minute but he finds a crumpled piece of paper on the map table.

    Jolting forward he unwraps the note with trembling fingers.

     

    (2) Country Holmes Apple Pie………$23.00

    Lover’s Double Smoothie……………$5.00

    He casts the paper aside in frustration before he can make it to the taxes. He runs a hand through his hair and he lets the paper drop.

    That’s when he sees it: blue ink on the reverse side of the bill.

    It’s Cass illegibly scribble alright.

     

    Do you want to be my boyfriend?

     

    Yes

     

    No

     

    Maybe

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    1,267
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    6
    Kudos:
    136
    Bookmarks:
    11
    Hits:
    1270
  9. Tags
    Summary

    “Sam, what’s wrong?” Eileen cups his face trying to steady his frantic movements.

    Sam rests the bottle of whiskey to his side. “I think my brother is fucking an angel.”

    ...

    OR

    How I want the finale to go down.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    1,069
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    4
    Kudos:
    121
    Bookmarks:
    7
    Hits:
    1635
  10. Tags
    Summary

    Broke, struggling law student Sam Winchester finds out about a program that helps students like him survive life while scholarships pay for tuition. Sam just wishes that his friend had let him know he was calling and applying to receive a sugar daddy. With Beauty and the Beast themes underlying, Sam finds his life changing dramatically when mysterious Gabriel Milton accepts his application. Forced to move in with the man and quit his two jobs, Sam stresses with feeling lost and out of control, lashing out at the man who he had to ask to save him.

    Gabriel Milton, said mysterious sugar daddy, would normally fire a sugar baby for such behavior, but as it is, he is far too intrigued with Sam Winchester to let him go yet. When he steps up his game and goes the extra mile to help Sam out, he starts to see who the law student really is and why it is so hard for him to Let Gabriel help him, even when he desperately needs it. Two lonely men for two different reasons start to find out those reasons maybe don't matter as much as they thought they should anymore.

    Cue "Maybe there is something there that wasn't there before."

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    10,839
    Chapters:
    7/?
    Comments:
    41
    Kudos:
    100
    Bookmarks:
    22
    Hits:
    1190
  11. Tags
    Summary

    Dean hates witches, Dean hates curses, and above all, Dean hates being trapped in the Bunker with his brother while he heals. Especially considering he can no longer keep his mouth shut, and certain secrets might find their way out...

    Sam loves books, Sam loves hunting, and Sam really loves his brother. Only then he finds some things out from Dean and has to reconsider his position, because it's starting to look suspiciously like Sam might love his brother a little too much...

    Alt Summary:
    He keeps a list.
    Item a: Sam Winchester's laugh.
    Item b: Sam Winchester's smile.
    Item c: Sam Winchester's eyes.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    15,765
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Collections:
    1
    Comments:
    6
    Kudos:
    86
    Bookmarks:
    10
    Hits:
    1455
  12. Tags
    Summary

    "Hey."
    Cas says in a soft timid voice,
    His hand ceasing its movement in my hair,
    But not pulling away.

    "What's wrong Dean?"
    --------------------
    "I Know I don't say this often Dean,
    But I'm really proud of you.
    And I'm happy that you have finally found that slice of apple pie,
    You have been dreaming off our whole lives."
    ------------------------------------------
    "You Damn idjits!
    I have been standin out here in the boiling heat for 10 whole minutes!
    What did you guys forget ya invited company?"

    "Well hey Bobby,
    I missed you too."
    ---------------
    "Because it's not normal Dean and I don't want to push your boundaries and do something that may make you uncomfortable.
    Or ruin what we have when your little
    Or-"-
    --------------
    A four chaptered section in my ongoing series Little did you know.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    14,369
    Chapters:
    4/4
    Comments:
    34
    Kudos:
    106
    Bookmarks:
    4
    Hits:
    1876
  13. Tags
    Summary

    With the barrier weakening and the townspeople antsier with every day, the Winchester brothers find it hard to focus on anything that isn't the problem at hand. Sam tries to escape for a little while, but while his body was separated from everyone, his mind stayed in the heart of the gymnasium.

    Can a witch spell it out for him that the world isn't burdened on his shoulders? And will Sam listen?

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    3,647
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    2
    Kudos:
    44
    Bookmarks:
    7
    Hits:
    712
  14. Tags
    Summary

    This wasn't going the way Sam expected this to go. But in a twisted Sam missed the archangel. It wasn't only Lucifer who finally felt complete when he possessed Sam. Sam had felt so good, like nothing could hurt him anymore. He felt protected. And while Hallucifer had tortured him, Lucifer in the cage sometimes was kinder. And Sam missed him. The only thing that is holding him back, is Dean. Until Lucifer makes an offer, that Sam simply can't refuse. He offers salvation from this world. Sam says yes.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    4,177
    Chapters:
    2/?
    Comments:
    9
    Kudos:
    79
    Bookmarks:
    10
    Hits:
    779
  15. Tags
    Summary

    Dean is conducting an elicit affair with some enigmatic chick with no name and no discernible features. Sam, like a good brother he stalks them hoping to find some answers. Along the way some mistakes are made, a multitude of confused and terribly ill-informed deductions are made along with some really sappy love confessions.

    And when Sam finds out who the 'mystery woman' really is, just how well will he take it?

    OR

    Sam finds Dean in the Impala with a 'mystery woman,' and makes it his life's mission to find her.

    And he does.

    Except it was actually Cass the whole time.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    2,505
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    8
    Kudos:
    163
    Bookmarks:
    14
    Hits:
    1467
  16. Tags
    Summary

    "She can't possibly be in love with him, right? I mean, Sam is an accomplice to his brother's crimes," Spencer asked no one in particular as he paced around the room.

    Derek sighed, "I don't know, I mean, the way she looks at him is almost how she looks at you."

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    7,009
    Chapters:
    2/?
    Comments:
    13
    Kudos:
    44
    Bookmarks:
    11
    Hits:
    949
  17. Tags
    Summary

    Sam pulled up Skype and shot a quick text to Eileen to let her know that he was about to call her. She responded quickly with a thumbs up, and Sam pressed the video call button.

    "Hello, Sam." Eileen's smile was brilliant, and Sam felt his heart skip as her fingers moved quickly. "It's good to see you. It feels like it's been too long."

    "We talk every day." Sam blushed, his signing a little slower.

    "But it's not the same as seeing you."

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    782
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    2
    Kudos:
    22
    Bookmarks:
    2
    Hits:
    200
  18. Tags
    Summary

    tragic backstories and height differences

    what happens when Benny's vampire daughter falls for Sam Winchester?

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    2,465
    Chapters:
    1/?
    Comments:
    3
    Kudos:
    5
    Hits:
    104
  19. Tags
    Summary

    "I don't need a symbol to remind me how I feel about my brother."
    Set right after 10x5 'Fan Fiction'. No Wincest. Just two bros.
    Dean teases Sam about what Marie told him about the Samulet- how it's supposed to be a symbol for their brotherly love. Sam is unamused, and Dean wants to know why he's so weird about saying the freaking words out loud!!
    Sibling antics --> bonding ensues, and they're both a little less emotionally constipated for it afterwards!

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    870
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    2
    Kudos:
    18
    Hits:
    287
  20. Tags
    Summary

    Sam, unknowingly moves into his online best friend’s apartment. After three years of talking online to Candy, not knowing his name or where he lives, he moves into Gabriel Novak’s apartment. He now talks to Candy over text and unknowingly in person.

    Once Candy tells Moose that he finds his new roommate adorable, Sam figures he doesn’t have any chance with him anymore. So he begins to date a girl from college, Jessica.

    Will Gabe’s jealously and anxiety keep him from Sam and Moose all together or will they both realize they’re oblivious idiots and figure it out?

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    106,217
    Chapters:
    15/15
    Comments:
    14
    Kudos:
    101
    Bookmarks:
    14
    Hits:
    1862

Filters

Filter results:
Submit

Include

?
Include Ratings
Include Warnings
Include Categories
Include Fandoms
Include Characters
Include Relationships
Include Additional Tags

Exclude

?
Exclude Ratings
Exclude Warnings
Exclude Categories
Exclude Fandoms
Exclude Characters
Exclude Relationships
Exclude Additional Tags

More Options

Crossovers
Completion Status
Word Count
Date Updated
Submit

Pages Navigation